Battle Hymn Volume 1 includes two games: Gettysburg: The Tide Turns and Pea Ridge: The Struggle for Missouri and is a new brigade-level game system that simulates the chaos of the American Civil War using a simple activation system combined with a detailed combat system. The system’s designer, Eric Lee Smith, originated the chit-pull activation system in his game Panzer Command and later used it in Across Five Aprils, Battle Hymn’s forerunner, both published by Victory Games. Units are organized by command, usually divisions, and activate for movement when the command’s activation marker is picked from the cup. The system uses traditional mechanics for movement, with units differentiated by type, but adds a level of detail to combat that feels almost miniatures like. In fact, the system is designed for easy conversion to miniatures. When one side has the initiative they decide when their combat phase occurs, without it, you don’t know when it will happen.
Gettysburg: The Tide Turns needs no introduction as to subject, but the treatment is noteworthy. Using a graphics approach based upon the maps produced by the US Government after the war, the map is truly a work of art and was one of the many reasons that I was drawn to this game. There are six scenarios in the game, some of which have alternatives for additional variety.
Pea Ridge: The Struggle for Missouri simulates the decisive battle of Pea Ridge, which determined that Missouri would stay in the Union. It could have gone the other way. This is a classic meeting engagement with the Confederates on the offensive and outnumbering the Union for once.
Thanks for the unboxing looks like a well put together set of games. I really like the old SPI Pea Ridge game still have it.
Grant, Thanks for the unboxing of Battle Hymn Vol. I. I have had this game since it was introduced and it is an excellent ACW game that has a lot of detail but does not get bogged down with the complexities of combat during those years.
Your comments on the map, designed by Rob Shields were spot on. They look like something, as you said, an aide-de-camp might have ready for his commander. Regrettably you did not show the upper left corner of the map. To enhance the “flavor” of the game, Mr Shields added a box similar what is found on period maps noting that the “Engineering Department of the U.S. Army…” commissioned this map “surveyed on June 1878…” An amazing touch.
I have heard on the Compass Game site that Vol. II is being developed and will cover Shiloh and a second “small action” Western theater game like Pea Ridge.
An ACW gamer may nit-pick some of the game structure – I would have liked to seen a “Confused Order” chit added similar to the structure John Poniske had in his game Belmont for Compass Games Paper Wars magazine #87. – but that does not detract from the overall quality of this game.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the insight. I still have yet to play but am eagerly awaiting my opportunity.